English grammar is often full of complexities that can trip up even the most experienced writers. One such pitfall is the dangling modifier. A dangling modifier is a common grammatical error that can lead to confusion, ambiguity, and even unintended humour in writing. But what is a dangling modifier, and how can you fix them? In this blog post, we’ll delve into the definition of dangling modifiers, provide examples of how they occur, and explain how to correct them. We’ll also explore the difference between dangling modifiers and misplaced modifiers, another common grammatical issue.
What is a Dangling Modifier?
A dangling modifier is a word or phrase that modifies a word not clearly stated in the sentence. In other words, the modifier is left “dangling” because the word it is meant to describe is missing or unclear, leading to a confusing or illogical sentence.
Typically, dangling modifiers occur at the beginning of a sentence, though they can also appear at the end. They are often participial phrases—phrases that start with a verb ending in “-ing” or “-ed”—but they can also be infinitive phrases or other types of modifiers.
Examples of Dangling Modifiers:
- Running to catch the bus, my hat flew off.
(Who was running to catch the bus? The sentence suggests that it was the hat, which doesn’t make sense.) - Having finished the assignment, the television was turned on.
(Who finished the assignment? The sentence implies the television did, which is illogical.)
In both examples, the modifier (the participial phrase) is not clearly or logically connected to the noun it is supposed to modify, leading to confusion.
How to Fix Dangling Modifiers
Correcting a dangling modifier involves reworking the sentence so that the modifier is clearly and logically connected to the word it’s supposed to describe. This usually requires adding a subject to the main clause or revising the sentence structure.
Here are some strategies to fix dangling modifiers:
1. Add the Missing Subject
One of the most straightforward ways to fix a dangling modifier is to add the subject that the modifier is intended to describe. This ensures that the modifier is logically connected to the correct noun or pronoun.
Example:
- Incorrect: Running to catch the bus, my hat flew off.
- Corrected: Running to catch the bus, I lost my hat.
In the corrected sentence, “I” is added as the subject, making it clear who was running to catch the bus.
2. Rewrite the Sentence
Sometimes, adding the missing subject might not be enough or might result in an awkward sentence. In such cases, it’s best to rewrite the sentence to ensure clarity.
Example:
- Incorrect: Having finished the assignment, the television was turned on.
- Corrected: After finishing the assignment, I turned on the television.
In this revised sentence, the action is directly connected to the correct subject, “I,” making the meaning clear.
3. Change the Modifier
Another way to correct a dangling modifier is to rephrase the modifier itself so that it doesn’t dangle.
Example:
- Incorrect: To improve his performance, the new routine was practised daily.
- Corrected: To improve his performance, he practised the new routine daily.
By rephrasing the sentence, the modifier is now clearly connected to the subject “he,” eliminating the dangling modifier.
Dangling Modifier vs Misplaced Modifier
Dangling modifiers are often confused with misplaced modifiers, but they are distinct issues. While both involve a modifier that is incorrectly placed, their differences lie in the relationship between the modifier and the word it modifies.
Dangling Modifier:
As discussed, a dangling modifier occurs when the modifier has no clear word to describe, making the sentence illogical or unclear.
Example:
- Incorrect: Flying over the city, the skyscrapers looked magnificent.
(The sentence suggests that the skyscrapers are flying over the city.)
Misplaced Modifier:
A misplaced modifier, on the other hand, is a modifier that is incorrectly placed in the sentence, creating ambiguity or confusion. However, unlike a dangling modifier, the word it modifies is present in the sentence—it’s just in the wrong place.
Example:
- Incorrect: She almost drove her kids to school every day.
(This suggests she didn’t quite manage to drive them every day.) - Corrected: She drove her kids to school almost every day.
In this example, the word “almost” was misplaced, changing the intended meaning of the sentence. The correction involves moving “almost” closer to what it’s supposed to modify.
More Examples of Dangling Modifiers
To further illustrate how dangling modifiers can be problematic and how to correct them, here are a few more examples:
Example 1:
- Incorrect: Hiking the trail, the birds chirped melodiously.
(The sentence implies that the birds were hiking the trail.) - Corrected: Hiking the trail, I heard the birds chirping melodiously.
Example 2:
- Incorrect: While baking in the oven, I burned the cookies.
(The sentence suggests that “I” was baking in the oven.) - Corrected: While the cookies were baking in the oven, I accidentally burned them.
Example 3:
- Incorrect: After reading the book, the plot was still confusing.
(The sentence suggests that the plot read the book.) - Corrected: After I read the book, the plot was still confusing.
Tips for Avoiding Dangling Modifiers
Dangling modifiers are easy to overlook, especially in complex sentences. Here are some tips to help you avoid them:
1. Identify the Modifier and Its Target
When proofreading your writing, always identify the modifier and check that it’s clearly modifying the correct word or phrase. Ask yourself: What or who is this modifier describing? Is that word clearly present in the sentence?
2. Read Aloud
Reading your sentences aloud can help you catch awkward phrasing or ambiguous constructions. If a sentence sounds confusing or off, it might be because of a dangling or misplaced modifier.
3. Simplify Complex Sentences
If a sentence is long or complicated, consider breaking it into shorter, simpler sentences. This can make it easier to ensure that each modifier is correctly placed and clearly connected to the word it describes.
4. Use Active Voice
Passive constructions often lead to dangling modifiers because the subject of the action is unclear. Whenever possible, use active voice to make your sentences clearer and more direct.
Example:
- Passive: Running down the street, the ball was kicked by the boy.
- Active: Running down the street, the boy kicked the ball.
The active voice makes it clear who is performing the action, reducing the risk of dangling modifiers.
Conclusion
Dangling modifiers are a common but easily correctable error in English grammar. By understanding what a dangling modifier is and how it differs from a misplaced modifier, you can improve the clarity and precision of your writing. Correcting dangling modifiers involves ensuring that every modifier is clearly and logically connected to the word it’s intended to describe.
Struggling with grammar and sentence structure? Our professional proofreading services can help with any document, from commercial reports to academic essays. Get a bespoke quote and let us polish your writing.
